A Note about Sugarbush Draft Horses

I see it over and over again, and no matter how many times it's said, it's still wrong. "Sugarbush Drafts are just an Appaloosa Draft Cross". Uh.... no. The Sugarbush Draft Horse was a breed created many years ago in Ohio. While the initial cross was made using Percherons to Appaloosas, in the many generations following, the breed has been solidified into a consistent type. Saying these horses are "just" a draft cross makes as much sense as saying that AQHA horses are "just" a Thoroughbred cross, American Cream Drafts are "just" a dilute Belgian, or that Morgans are "just" a grade.

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Conformation Clinic: The Shoulder

Previously we have talked about the horse's Head, and the conformation of the Neck.  Working our way back one more section, we get to the shoulder of the horse.

The shoulder of the horse is a very misunderstood, yet extremely important area of conformation.  The shoulder affects much of the horse's movement, it's balance, it's neck attachment, and is what makes the difference between a bouncy trot, and a wonderful smooth trot.  One of the main problems I see in conversations about a horse's shoulder is what exactly the shoulder is.

The mare above is a perfect example of the confusion.  Notice the dark varnish mark against the base of her neck?  That is not her shoulder angle.  See the shape of her shoulder blade just under the skin?  Nope, that's not her shoulder angle either.  The divot where her neck meets her body?  you guessed, not her shoulder angle.

So what IS the shoulder angle then?
The slope of the shoulder is the "angle" that most people refer to when talking about equine conformation.  This is not the "shoulder angle" exactly, but it is an important piece of conformation to understand.

Here's a good diagram of what we're going to be talking about:
The horse shown above is SHC O Sweet Surprise, or Sweetie.  This is my SDHR filly shown at 18 months of age.

The slope of the shoulder is what many people refer to as the "shoulder angle".  I actually have been known to do this myself.  It's easier to say, and kind of flows off the tongue.  Technically though, it's not correct, but I'll get to that in a minute.

The Ideal Shoulder Slope
The shoulder slope, or slope of the shoulder (the terms are interchangeable) ideally should be a 45 degree angle, as measured between the top of the withers and the point of the shoulder.  The problem is, no one ever talks about what we should measure this angle against.  A line does not make an angle.  Recently, I came up against this problem when doing a conformation analysis of a young colt.  His shoulder looked like it should be "good" to my eye, but my measurements kept telling me that it was all wrong.

The 2 red dots in that image are the palpable points on the horse.  This means the parts you can reach your hand up, and feel.  The yellow dots are the points we talked about in the previous post, regarding the neck.  They come into play as well.  The top of the withers, the upper red dot, is often where the mane hair stops growing, but is always the center of the rounded bony wither structure.  This is the same place we use to measure our horse's height.  The lower red dot is the point of the chest.  This is the hard bony point you can feel when you touch your horse.

The angle formed where the red line meets the black one is 49 degrees (on Sweetie above).  A 45 degree angle is the ideal, but a shoulder between 45 degrees and 50 degrees is considered "good".

How to measure Shoulder Slope
When you look at that line though, you can see that it's an imaginary line, and there's no true edge or angle on the horse in that section in real life.  This is where a lot of problems come in.  Google shoulder angle, and you'll see it.  Horses with lines drawn where their neck meets their body, angles that have nothing to do with the shoulder slope, and other random lines placed on ponies through the use of MS Paint and other digital drawing software.
These are examples of the myriad types of "shoulder angle" lines I have seen drawn on conformation critiques.  Only the red line is the correct one.  I don't even want to tell you what the others are connected to, because that might cause confusion.

Most often, this line (the one I have depicted in red) is measured against the line of the horizon, or a perfectly horizontal line.  So, does that mean that as a horse ages, the horse gets a better or worse shoulder?  Well, no. Even though the horse grows, and its relation to the ground changes (hip high, level, shoulder high, and such) the horse's angles stay consistent against its own body.  If you do a whole lot of complicated math, measuring and add more colored lines then there are colors to use, well, you can determine the proper angle.  Now, the easy way is to measure the horse at a few stages of growth, and average out the results.  Another good way is to measure the horse against its structural center of balance.

This green line is Sweetie's structural center of balance.  It is measured from where her femur meets the hip (the ball and socket joint of the hind leg) to where  her spine at the base of her neck meets her body/shoulder.  As you can see, Sweetie is slightly uphill, structurally.  When the slope of her shoulder is measured against that green line, her shoulder slope is 50 degrees. Only a 1 degree difference.

Now, "eye balling it" I look at Sweetie and tend to think she's a hair straighter then I like in the shoulder.  A measurement of 50 degrees sounds just about right to me.  Considering that she was at a phase of growth that had her "shoulder high" the measurement makes a bit more sense to me.  Since she's only slightly gangly, this angle is only a degree different then if she is measured against the horizontal.  In other words, not a big deal in her case.

But if she was at a downhill stage of growth, this measurement would stay pretty much consistent.

This is because if her front legs are short, or her hind ones are long, or her bits and pieces can't figure out where they want to be, her spine still has to run through her shoulder area, across the back, and into the hip.  The spine isn't going to be shifting its path in her body, and her hips and shoulder aren't going to be suddenly changing the way they attach to the other bones in her body.  Oh sure, she's an ugly mess in the picture above, but structurally, she's still pretty decent.

Shoulder Angle
Now, you remember that shoulder angle we talked about?  Well I want to touch on it a bit today, but will go more in depth on it tomorrow.  You see, the Shoulder Angle is really more a part of the foreleg, and not the horse's shoulder.

The actual "shoulder angle" is the angle created from the slop of the shoulder, and the slope of the humerus (upper arm bone, which is located in the chest of a horse).  The top red dot is on her withers, the next lowest is at the point of her shoulder, and the lowest red dot there is at the point of her elbow.  You can feel the bony part of a horse's elbow, and the range of location varies by conformation.

This angle is determined by the set of the scapula (shoulder blade) in the horse, and the length of the humerus (fore arm bone).  For Sweetie, this angle is 87 degrees, and I have to keep in mind that her leg is set slightly back, which will raise the point of elbow slightly..  This angle should ideally be at least 90 degrees, and up to 120 degrees is considered good.  The larger this angle is, the easier it will be for her to swing her legs forward, and raise her knees to her chest.

The longer the bone in the forearm, the lower the point of elbow will be, and the larger the angle of the shoulder.  The set of the scapula (or slope of shoulder) is not nearly as important on its own, as it is in relation to this angle.  A very upright shoulder with a horizontal humerus could result in an angle of 90 degrees or more, and that straight shouldered horse would still be a nice ride, AND be able to haul weight.

The Straight Shoulder
Wait, did I just say something that made it sound like there's a good reason for a straight shoulder?  Yep, I sure did!

Back in the day when the horse was the only form of horse power there was, draft horses were used to pull weight.  Need a tree stump removed?  Just hitch up your power house, and it'll be gone in no time!  For these horses, the straight shoulder is ideal.

Photo: Carol Mitchell
The more sloped a horse's shoulder, the more work that horse has to do when pulling weight behind him forward.  This is because the horse has to pull the weight not only forward, but also up.  The straighter the shoulder, the less "up" and more "forward" the horse's effort gives.

Look at this lovely hard working Belgian draft here.  This is a perfect example of a horse leaning into the harness, and using his conformation to his advantage.  He pushes his shoulder blade against the collar, working as a lever against the actual harness, uses his neck to adjust the balance low and forward, and his hips and hind legs are the power to move what ever he is hitched to.

A good way to envision this, is to thing of moving the horse's collar, and the weight attached to it, with a pole.  You can either poke the pole in the ground, and heave on it - in which case the point of the pole closest to your hand would move more vertically, leaving the pole in a straight up and down angle when you're done, or you could try to shove the pole under the harness and lift it up, keeping the same sloped angle, but wearing out your arm and back muscles.

Now lets look at him with some colored lines.  The red of course is the horse's shoulder angle.  Notice how upright his shoulder slope is, and how horizontal his humerus is.  The resulting angle is nearly 90 degrees, but again this horse's legs are in motion, so we give him a buffer.

The green arrow is the direction of force working against the horse.  It is down and back, and the motion of this picture makes it easy to see.  The collar is almost perfectly perpendicular to the direction of force.  This makes the horse's effort that much more efficient, even though the horse technically has a "bad" and upright shoulder slope.

The Over View
When talking about equine conformation, shoulder is always one of the most talked about things of a horse.  Often the horse's shoulder slope is used as proof of the horse's quality, and yet, on its own it means very little.

The angle of the shoulder and upper arm bones is the true measure of a horse's gait.  And open (90 degree or greater) angle allows the horse freedom of movement, and a gait that is a pleasure to ride. While this is most commonly found in horses with a shoulder slope between 45 and 50 degrees, it is not exclusive to the slope of the shoulder.  The length of the upper arm bone is actually the more important feature.

And while we've been told that a "straight shoulder" is a horrible thing in a horse, few people truly know what that means, or why a straight shoulder even exists.  The horse's conformation is not something that can be looked at in bits and pieces, but rather we need to look at a horse as a whole, and measure its form against its function.

The Sugarbush Draft Horse
I always include how this applies to the Sugarbush Draft Horses here at the end.  This is because our horses are a bit misunderstood, and our method of reviving the breed (allowing cross breeding to unregistered horses with the right conformation) confuses many people.

The ideal Sugarbush Draft Horse is built for riding, and for pulling light carriages.  These horses are not typical drafts, and are poorly suited to hauling heavy weights because of their conformation.  The ideal shoulder slope is 45 to 50 degrees, with the average SDHR horse being on the high side of "ideal".  Much of this is due to the ancestry of other draft breeds - breeds that were bred to pull weight.

The important thing though, is that the Sugarbush Draft has a moderately open shoulder angle.  Most SDHR horses have a shoulder angle between 90 and 95 degrees, and breeding for openness between the scapular and humerus is encouraged.

The Sugarbush Draft Horse has a moderate leg action, and a lovely forward extension because of the shape of this angle.  This means that the rider feels a smooth, but forward gait under them, with little jarring.


  1. Beautiful explanation.  I'm going to read this again & again. 

  2. Great explanation and diagrams.  I finally 'get' it!

  3. How do you personally search for data for your new articles, which search networks do you often turn to?

  4. When the code continues to be came into successfully, all the issues is
    usually credited to your account. Totally
    free Xbox live codes are also given by some console sellers as
    being a definite incentive on buying Ps3 live. Article Source:
    best microsoft Points generator to look for is the second type which gives
    more guarantee of being successful that the first or
    the third type and.

    Feel free to surf to my blog ... free microsoft points

  5. Nevertheless, Romney's Twitter account trails Barack Obama's Twitter account by more
    than 16 million followers. Here's the top ten: after Obama in 4th place is a recent arrival to the top ten, reality star Kim Kardashian in 5th, followed by Katy Perry in 6th, in 7th place is actor Ashton Kutcher, then talk show host Ellen De - Generes in 8th, Taylor Swift in 9th and Oprah Winfrey in 10th. Ask your friends and followers to digg, retweet a post for you because that will feature you on the Digg homepage and you will surely have increased number of followers on twitter.

    Here is my website: Buy cheap Twitter Followers

  6. I am curious which blogging platform you are using?
    I'm new to running a blog and have been thinking about using the Quizilla platform. Do you consider this is a good foundation to start with? I would be very thankful if I could ask you some questions through e-mail so I can learn a bit more prior to getting started. When you have some free time, please be sure to get in touch with me at: annettacabrera@t-online.de. Appreciate it

    My blog site

  7. Now this should be done carefully as different Xbox games offers different amount of free codes.
    Totally free Xbox live codes are also given by some console sellers as being a definite incentive on buying
    Ps3 live. The second type is the almost legitimate programs that are encountered less than the fake type and has been created with good intentions and was filled with legal, valid codes.

    Also visit my weblog: msp codes

  8. It is caused by the hormonal problems, weight gain, and many other factors.
    Article Source: tested cream is a inexpensive and fast way to remove cellulite.
    There may be a new and innovative cellulite treatment available now: cryotherapy.

    Here is my weblog ... how do you get rid of cellulite with exercise

  9. It is caused by the hormonal problems, weight gain, and many
    other factors. A cellulite reduction treatment using a soft bristled body brush
    ($10) to brush the treatment areas where reduction is desired.
    The best way of dealing with cellulite & stretch marks ( is by choosing a
    treatment option and sticking to it.

    my page :: How to get rid of cellulite naturally

  10. Mega Wedgie in 6 Flags Hurricane Harbor is a person of the most
    entertaining water slides in the globe

    My blog post: continue

  11. Cellulite is an unsightly dimpled appearance, especially around the thighs.
    And also some of the underweight people are also such complaints.
    You do not have to perform these exercises every day, all you
    need is to do them three times (3x) a week for about thirty minutes each session.

    Look at my web blog Get rid of cellulite

  12. A short day trip to the coast would be a great family get-a-way that should not cost much, most
    definitely if you are located close to the coast

    Feel free to surf to my blog additional information

  13. So, at this point, let me stop and make a couple of comments:
    First, put everything that youdon't want to lose in a secure place

    my site go to my site